IDCPPA Research Seminar - 01 October - Jesse Zhou - Political Will, Institutional Fragility: Competing Narratives in South Africa’s NHI Debate
You are kindly invited to the IDCPPA Research Seminar on
Thursday, 01 October 2026, 14:00 – 15:30 SAST.
CSSR Seminar Room 4.29
Robert Leslie Social Sciences Building
University of Cape Town
Please request a video link if you wish to attend online.
Speaker
PhD Student Jesse Zhou
University of Cape Town, Sociology Department
Political Will, Institutional Fragility: Competing Narratives in South Africa’s NHI Debate
Abstract:
This presentation examines how South Africa's major political parties framed the National Health Insurance Bill (NHIB) during parliamentary public hearings, arguing that leadership politics, expressed through divergent party narratives, played a critical role in shaping the bill's contested passage.
Drawing on parliamentary submissions, committee minutes, and Hansard records, the presentation traces nine competing narratives advanced by the ANC, DA, EFF, COSATU, SACP, and smaller parties. The ANC framed support for the NHIB as synonymous with support for universal health coverage (UHC), casting the private health sector as the primary obstacle to equitable access, while COSATU and SACP reinforced this position through a working-class solidarity lens. In contrast, the DA and Freedom Front Plus framed the bill as fiscally reckless, constitutionally flawed, and destabilising to the private health sector, while the EFF rejected it as insufficiently radical, characterising it as a mechanism that would outsource healthcare to private profiteers rather than nationalise the system. The chapter further shows how the NHIB's passage was entangled with narratives of ANC electioneering, procedural irregularity, and, most damagingly, the Digital Vibes and State Capture scandals, which lent credibility to opposition claims about weak oversight and ministerial overreach.
The analysis reveals a structural paradox: the ANC's ideological cohesion, bolstered by its tripartite alliance, coexisted with profound institutional fragility exposed by corruption scandals and concerns raised by opposition parties. The political will of implementing the NHIB outpaced institutional capacity and cross-sectoral legitimacy, producing a polarised and unresolved terrain of business-state relations.
Bio:
Jesse Zhou is a PhD candidate at UCT. Jesse’s work focuses on the politics of healthcare reform in South Africa. My doctoral research examines the implementation of National Health Insurance (NHI) and the influence of sectoral interests on the development of Universal Health Coverage. Drawing on a business state relations perspective, his research explores how political, economic and institutional interests shape health policy and the distribution of power within South Africa’s healthcare system.